12 Best Breads for Grilled Cheeses

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

When you are looking for the bread for grilled cheese sandwiches, everyone will have a different opinion on which one is their favorite. As long as the bread is thick enough to be picked up after grilling and has a nice crunch it will make a great grilled cheese sandwich. Here are a few brands that always get high marks. 

  1. Martin’s – Sandwich Potato Bread

If you are looking for the classic greasy grilled cheese sandwich your grandmother would make this bread will deliver. While the bread is not going to be good for your waistline the nostalgia may just be worth the extra calories. 

  • San Francisco Boudin Bakery Sourdough

This hearty bread will make a great grilled cheese sandwich. This bread is so hearty it would even hold up to you getting creative and adding other ingredients to the sandwich as well. This choice is going to be high in carbs so if you are worried about your figure you may want to pass. 

  • White Post Farm – Pumpkin Bread

If you are the person that has to have everything pumpkin flavored in fall, this is probably an option you will love. Pumpkin and cheese is a unique combination but some people swear by this combo.

  • Pepperidge Farm – Swirl Raisin Cinnamon Breakfast Bread

This choice will likely take you on a nostalgic ride as well. This sweet bread and ooeey gooey cheese make a really sweet treat. This bread is very loaded with sugar so it is a splurge if you are trying to be healthy with your diet. 

  • Stern’s Bakery – Kosher Challah Bread 

This will take anyone with a Jewish grandmother right down memory lane. If you want a grilled cheese sandwich that is loaded with nostalgia and carbs, this will be a great splurge now and again. 

  • New Grains – Gluten-Free English Muffins

This is a great option for a grilled cheese sandwich for anyone that can not eat gluten. It is still a little high in carbs but if your only concern is no gluten it may work well for you. 

  • ThinSlim Foods – Love-The-Taste Low Carb Bread

This bread option is popular because it is low in carbs and comes close to all most capturing the mouthfeel and taste of bread. Most people do find it a little dry so make sure that you use a good bit of fat when using it to make a grilled cheese sandwich. 

  • Dorothy Lane Market – New York Rye

Having a grilled cheese sandwich on a thick piece of New York rye is always a classic and this brand always delivers a great tasting loaf of rye bread. Like all bread, it is high in carbs though. 

  • Chompies – Low Carb Multigrain Bread

This low-carb option stands up great to being grilled and it almost develops a crunch. This bread is dry as the other low-carb option and just tastes a little off when used to make a grilled cheese sandwich. 

  1. SoLo Carb Bread – Harvest Wheat

Like with the other 2 low-carb bread options listed so far this one is also a little dry. You will want to make sure to use plenty of fat to make it enjoyable. The texture of this option is nice but it is extremely dry. 

  1. Arnold Jewish Rye- Pumpernickel Bread

Pumpernickle was just made for cheese it is amazing in fondue and makes a great grilled cheese sandwich. The bread is of course high in carbs though and will not be kind to your waistline.

  1. Uprising – Superfood Cubes

This is a low-carb bread option that will blow your socks off. It tastes and feels just like traditional sourdough bread and toast beautifully. If you are looking for a guilt-free grilled cheese sandwich, this is the bread you should choose.  

Time To Get Cheesy

No matter which bread you choose, you know what to make for dinner tonight. Get your favorite loaf of bread and treat yourself to a delicious grilled cheese sandwich and tomato soup. You will not regret it.


What do you think?

%d bloggers like this: